Commentary

Those who want to race, should race! Those who don't will be banned?

MotoGP did not cover itself in glory in handling doubts over Qatar. Now Formula 1 has to make a decision. Will it learn lessons from the PR fiasco?

Those who want to race, should race! Those who don't will be banned?
Comments

MotoGP is currently packing up its tents in Qatar. Formula 1 is supposed to set theirs up there in three weeks. According to the current plan.

With less than 21 days to go, the final verdict on whether the current season will end in the Middle East is still pending.

For weeks, Imola has been lying in wait to step in as a replacement venue just in case. Now the Italians also need clear answers.

Even if 19 out of 22 aren't up for it

The two-wheeled spectacle did not pass without friction. Yamaha boycotted, and 19 of the 22 riders signed a statement expressing their discontent.

So it is safe to say: if it had been up to those who (should) be at the center of the sport, the Qatar GP would not have taken place like this.

With world champion and standings leader Marc Marquez, the most prominent among them made no secret on site of preferring to be "somewhere else": "I arrived on the latest possible flight and will leave on the earliest possible one."

Wolff misses the mark

Toto Wolff was not pleased with any of this. Asked about how things went in MotoGP, the Mercedes team principal said: "I think when drivers who have no geopolitical idea of what is going on speak up, but have an audience listening to them, it creates media value."

Denying geopolitical understanding simply because people raise concerns about their physical safety is a bold stance. When instructions are handed to the MotoGP paddock in Qatar on how to act correctly in the event of a military attack, it is clear enough that you don't even need a clear picture of the "big picture."

Common sense would back out the moment such considerations become necessary.

After all, it is "only" about sport. And while employment contracts may revolve around riding a horsepower rocket, the danger of having a real one drop on your head from above is hardly covered.

You don't have to, someone else will

Those in charge of MotoGP seem to see it differently.

Recently, there was talk of bans for riders who did not compete in Qatar for the final two races of the season. Whether it would have actually come to that cannot be answered due to a lack of further withdrawals after Yamaha's complete retreat.

test
In Jeddah 2022 trennten die F1 nur Kilometer von einer Rakete
Foto: ©IMAGO / PanoramiC

Thus, Wolff's Solomon-like approach falls flat: "Those who want to drive should drive. Those who don't want to should leave it. It's that simple, and everyone can make their own decision - I respect that."

Not without the slightly threatening addition: "Maybe that's also an opportunity to give someone else a chance."

What does the GPDA say?

Formula 1 itself refers to "international guidelines," i.e. travel restrictions, flight cancellations, warnings, and government assessments.

"In my opinion, you have to be able to rely on that," Wolff notes.

However, it is a fact that, from the perspective of his home country, the third of four possible travel warning levels applies to Qatar and Abu Dhabi. It is also a fact that airlines like Lufthansa have postponed resuming flights to the United Arab Emirates until late November.

For now, astonishingly little is heard from the F1 drivers themselves about their desire to put themselves in this situation. Given the latent urge not to ruffle any feathers anywhere, that is hardly surprising. All the more respect to Marc Marquez.

Unlike their MotoGP counterparts, however, they have a union at hand with the GPDA that could exert pressure much more effectively.

It can hardly get any closer

In the end, it will be — as is so often the case — a choice between "money" or "sport."

The stakes are high, because the consequences of an incident would be unbearable. The probability may be low, but in Jeddah 2022 a missile strike just a few kilometers from the track became a reality. Probably for that reason as well, the threshold for pain seems to be (too) high.

On the track, the mantra "safety comes above all" has taken root after many tragedies. Off the track, the factors of money and politics are still tugging at reason.

Comments

You can find the original LAOLA1 article here.